Mid-season thoughts on RideBack

After five episodes of juggling two completely different shows, in episode six RideBack finally brought action into the story with the GGP’s use of White Rides and Rin’s arrest. Although it’s arguable as to whether RideBack was exciting and eventful prior to episode six, we know that RideBack has a bit of an identity problem. While wanting to show off the ridebacks and how awesome they may be, the show also wishes to tackle serious “concepts like political resistance.” In that sense, we are seeing two shows that Madhouse has unsuccessfully mashed together. One of the RideBack manga readers notes that “few manga transform themselves completely as regularly as Ride Back does; every volume or two it seems to smoothly change genres completely.” Perhaps it isn’t a surprise that the anime adaptation is trying to do the same, but it’s disappointing that it’s failing to do so.

Overall I agree with jpmeyer and his thoughts on RideBack. Its major themes are definitely a mismatch. I cannot say if the manga is excellent as Andrew Cunningham makes it seem, but the anime needs a focus that isn’t the ridebacks. It’s not to say the machines aren’t awesome, but more emphasis must be placed on the political resistance. The ridebacks may be a vehicle (no pun intended) to move the story along, but if we aren’t seeing a just cause in fighting the GGP nearly halfway through the show, why are we watching? Prior to episode seven, there was little reason to empathize with revolutionaries and those against the GGP. All the viewers knew was that the GGP took over the world through militaristic force. Big deal. At least in Code Geass, we knew there was something wrong: the Japanese were being treated like dirt.

Episode seven was pleasing. We now clearly understand what the GGP is like; who tortures a high school student into falsely admitting murder? I have a reason to oppose the GGP and want to support the rebels. Okakura is taking action and a small conflict arises between Ryunnosuke and Karenbak, hinting at a future struggle within the government. The BMA has abducted Rin and she has met that other rider from the terrorist incident. We see the plot finally moving forward, and I’m quite happy with what’s been given to us.

Now the question is, will Madhouse do a good job with the remaining five episodes? Episode seven turned it around, but half the season is already over. RideBack has to consistently hit a home run at each of its next five at-bats, or it’ll lose the game and end up a show that can easily be forgotten.


This post is tagged , , ,

One Response

  1. I didn’t really get the GGP’s motivation in episode 7. By torturing Rin’s brother into a confession they knew to be false, I have to ask what was the actual point there? If they’re going to flagrantly circumvent a just judicial process, why not just forge his signature and skip the coerced confession?

    One could counter that the GGP’s operators may derive some sort of pleasure from torture, but I don’t think the scene conveyed that at all. Truthfully, the whole scene felt forced, as if to say to the viewer, “the GGP are eeeeeeevil!”

    Why do the GGP even need justification to roll out the White RideBacks? Don’t they rule the world as it is? Just say you’re going to do it and be done with it.

    I thought this shift in focus would do wonders for RideBack. Now I miss the days when it was merely a sports anime.

Leave a Reply

Categories

Polls

Do you have and frequently use Twitter?

  • Yes (47%, 7 Votes)
  • No (27%, 4 Votes)
  • Have one, but don't use it much (20%, 3 Votes)
  • What's Twitter? (6%, 1 Votes)

Total Voters: 15

Loading ... Loading ...